Nursing Home Ratings: How Medicare’s Star Ratings Work in 2026

Younger family member helping a senior man look up nursing home ratings on a laptop

Table of Contents

Nursing home ratings are the fastest way to narrow a long list of facilities to a short one. But the overall star on Medicare’s Care Compare site is not an average, and it can hide serious problems. This guide explains how Medicare’s nursing home star ratings are calculated in 2026, what changed in the last 18 months, which icons matter more than the stars, and how to use the ratings to choose a nursing home for a parent or spouse.

Quick answers

  • Who rates nursing homes? The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) gives every Medicare- or Medicaid-certified nursing home 1 to 5 stars on Medicare.gov Care Compare.
  • What is rated? An overall rating plus three separate ratings: health inspections, staffing and quality measures.
  • What counts most? Health inspections. The overall rating starts from the inspection stars, and staffing and quality can only move it up or down by one star each.
  • Is it a curve? Yes. Inspection stars are graded against other homes in the same state: the top 10% get 5 stars and the bottom 20% get 1 star.
  • What to check first: the red abuse icon, Special Focus Facility status, the inspection report itself and the staffing star, before the overall rating.
  • New in 2026: a gold trophy icon (since 8 October 2026) for homes eligible for a shorter “risk-based” inspection, and tougher quality-measure cut points from the July 2026 refresh.

What are nursing home ratings?

Most families mean the Five-Star Quality Rating System, which CMS added to its website in 2008 and now publishes on Care Compare. Every certified nursing home gets four ratings, each from 1 star (much below average) to 5 stars (much above average):

  • Overall rating – a combined score built from the three ratings below.
  • Health inspections – based on what state inspectors found during on-site surveys and complaint investigations.
  • Staffing – based on payroll-reported nurse hours per resident and staff turnover.
  • Quality measures – based on resident assessment data and Medicare claims, such as falls with injury, pressure ulcers and hospital readmissions.

The ratings cover roughly 14,700 nursing homes. That includes most skilled nursing facilities, which are the same buildings when they provide short-term rehab after a hospital stay. Assisted living communities are not rated by CMS because they are licensed by states, not certified by Medicare.

Younger family member helping a senior man look up nursing home ratings on a laptop
Photo: Pexels

How Medicare calculates the overall star rating

The overall rating is not an average of the three domain ratings. CMS builds it in steps, starting from the health inspection rating:

StepRuleEffect
1Start with the health inspection ratingSets the base (1–5 stars)
2Staffing rating is 5 stars+1 star
2Staffing rating is 1 star−1 star
3Quality measure rating is 5 stars+1 star
3Quality measure rating is 1 star−1 star
4Health inspection rating is 1 starStaffing and quality together can raise the overall by no more than one star
–LimitsThe result can’t go above 5 stars or below 1 star

Example: a home with 3 inspection stars, 5 staffing stars and 2 quality stars gets 4 stars overall (3 + 1 for staffing, no change for quality). A home with 4 inspection stars, 1 staffing star and 5 quality stars also gets 4 stars (4 − 1 + 1). Two very different homes, same overall rating. That is why you should always open the three domain ratings.

Since July 2022, a 4-star staffing rating no longer adds a star. Only 5-star staffing does, while 1-star staffing always costs a star.

The health inspection rating

State survey agencies inspect each nursing home on behalf of CMS about once a year (and at least every 15 months), plus whenever there is a complaint. Inspectors cite “deficiencies” and grade each one by severity (from potential for minimal harm up to immediate jeopardy) and scope (isolated, a pattern or widespread). CMS turns these into points. More serious and more widespread problems score more points, and a lower score is better.

What changed in 2025

Since the July 2025 refresh, the rating uses only the two most recent standard inspections instead of three. The newest one counts for 75% and the older one for 25%. Complaint and infection-control inspections still use a three-year lookback. CMS said about 80% of homes would see no change but roughly 20% would see meaningful changes, so a rating that moved in mid-2025 may reflect the new formula rather than a change in care.

Graded within your state

Inspection stars are relative to other nursing homes in the same state, because states inspect differently:

  • Top 10% (lowest scores) – 5 stars
  • Middle 70% – 2, 3 or 4 stars (about 23.33% each)
  • Bottom 20% – 1 star

This means a 5-star inspection rating in one state and a 5-star rating in another are not directly comparable. It also means one in five homes in every state will always have a 1-star inspection rating, however good or bad the state’s homes are overall.

The staffing rating

Staffing comes from the Payroll-Based Journal, the payroll data nursing homes must submit to CMS each quarter. Hours are case-mix adjusted, so a home caring for sicker residents is expected to staff more. Six measures earn up to 380 points:

MeasureWhat it showsMax points
Registered nurse (RN) hours per resident per dayHow much RN time each resident gets100
Total nurse hours per resident per dayRN + LPN/LVN + nurse aide time100
Total nurse hours per resident per day on weekendsWhether staffing drops on Saturdays and Sundays50
Total nurse staff turnoverShare of nursing staff who left over 12 months50
RN turnoverShare of RNs who left over 12 months50
Administrator turnoverNumber of administrators who left over 12 months30

CMS can also cut a home’s staffing rating if its payroll data fails an audit. Staffing is one of the most useful ratings for families, because it reflects how much hands-on time residents get. The Long Term Care Community Coalition’s February 2026 report found nursing homes reported an average of 3.90 nurse hours per resident per day, against 4.94 expected for their residents’ needs, and 87% of homes staffed below expected levels. Look at the actual hours on Care Compare, not just the star.

The federal minimum staffing rule (24/7 RN and 3.48 total nurse hours) was repealed in early 2026, so Care Compare is now the main public check on staffing levels.

Caregiver pushing a senior woman in a wheelchair at a care facility
Photo: Pexels

The quality measure rating

The quality rating combines 15 measures: some for long-stay residents (people who live there) and some for short-stay residents (people there for rehab, usually after a hospital stay). Examples include:

  • Long-stay: falls with major injury, pressure ulcers, urinary tract infections, use of antipsychotic medication, decline in ability to do daily activities, hospitalizations and emergency room visits.
  • Short-stay: rehospitalization, emergency room visits, new or worsening pressure ulcers, function at discharge, and successful return home.

Care Compare shows separate long-stay and short-stay quality ratings. Use the one that matches your situation: short-stay for rehab after a hip replacement, long-stay for a parent who will live there.

2026 changes: CMS added Medicare and Medicaid claims and Medicare Advantage encounter data to the long-stay antipsychotic measure, so homes can no longer be judged on self-reported assessment data alone for that measure. From the 29 July 2026 refresh, CMS also raised the points needed for each quality star. Some homes lost a quality star, and sometimes an overall star, without any change in their care. More threshold increases are possible in January 2027.

Caution: most quality measures come from assessment data the nursing home itself reports. Consumer advocates have repeatedly found homes with 5-star quality ratings but poor inspection and staffing results. Treat a high quality star with poor inspections as a reason to dig deeper.

Icons that matter more than the stars

Red abuse icon

A red circle with a hand appears when a home was cited for abuse that harmed a resident in the past year, or for abuse that could have caused harm in each of the last two years. Homes with this icon have their inspection rating capped at 2 stars, so their overall rating can be no higher than 4 stars. In February 2026, 1,486 nursing homes carried the abuse icon. It stays on Care Compare for a year after a harm-level citation, or two years for repeated lower-level citations.

Special Focus Facility (SFF)

SFFs are homes with a long record of serious problems that CMS has placed under extra inspections. Care Compare does not show star ratings for current SFFs. CMS also publishes a monthly list of SFF candidates, homes with similar records that are not yet in the program. In February 2026 there were 87 SFFs and 440 candidates. A home graduates only after two consecutive standard surveys without serious problems. Be very cautious with any current SFF or candidate.

Gold trophy icon (new in October 2026)

Since 8 October 2026, Care Compare shows a trophy icon next to nursing homes eligible for CMS’s new risk-based survey, a shorter inspection for high performers. To qualify, a home needs a 5-star overall rating, accurate data reporting, no harm-level or substandard-care citations in the last survey cycle and no recent ownership change. 1,699 homes got the icon in the first release, and eligibility lasts six months at a time. Every home is still inspected at least every 15 months.

The trophy is a good sign, but not a guarantee. The Center for Medicare Advocacy and the National Consumer Voice found that no more than 54% of trophy homes would have qualified a year earlier. Some had recent fines, and 478 had not had a standard inspection in over a year. Read the inspection report even for a trophy home.

Chain and ownership ratings

Since July 2025, Care Compare also shows the average ratings of the chain or affiliated group that operates a nursing home. If a home has good stars but its chain averages 1 or 2 stars, ask how long the current management has been in place.

Recent changes to nursing home ratings

DateChangeWhat it means for families
July 2025Inspection rating uses 2 standard surveys (75/25), not 3Ratings react faster to recent inspections
30 July 2025Chain/affiliated-entity average ratings publishedYou can see the operator’s track record
Late 2025–2026Claims and Medicare Advantage data added to long-stay antipsychotic measureHarder to under-report antipsychotic use
29 July 2026Quality-measure star cut points raisedSome quality and overall stars dropped without a change in care
8 October 2026Gold trophy icon for risk-based survey eligibilityFlags top performers, but check the record

What nursing home ratings don’t tell you

  • Resident and family satisfaction. There is no satisfaction survey in the star rating.
  • Specific care needs. Ratings don’t show whether a home has a secure dementia unit, ventilator care or bariatric equipment. See memory care vs nursing home if dementia is the main need.
  • Very recent events. Inspection data can be months old, and some homes have gone more than a year without a standard inspection.
  • Cost and payment. Ratings say nothing about price or whether a home accepts Medicaid. See how much a nursing home costs and whether Medicaid pays for a nursing home.
  • Comparisons across states. Inspection stars are graded on a curve within each state.
Senior woman using a walker in a nursing home corridor
Photo: Pexels

How to use nursing home ratings to choose a home: 8 steps

Want to see local options first? Search senior living and care options near you.

  1. Make a long list on Care Compare. Search by ZIP code or city on Medicare.gov Care Compare and pick the nursing home tab. Add homes your loved one’s doctor, hospital discharge planner or friends recommend.
  2. Remove red flags first. Cross off current Special Focus Facilities and candidates, and look hard at any home with the red abuse icon.
  3. Open all four ratings. Prefer homes with at least 3 inspection stars and at least 3 staffing stars. For a long-term resident, look at the long-stay quality rating. For rehab, the short-stay one.
  4. Read the inspection report. On Care Compare, open “View all health inspections”. Look for harm-level citations (G or higher), repeat citations and problems relevant to your loved one, such as falls, pressure ulcers or medication errors.
  5. Check actual staffing numbers. Compare RN hours and total nurse hours with the state and national averages shown, and check weekend staffing and turnover. High turnover often means agency staff who don’t know the residents.
  6. Check penalties and ownership. Care Compare lists fines and payment denials from the past three years, plus the chain’s average ratings.
  7. Call your state’s long-term care ombudsman. Ombudsmen handle residents’ complaints and often know which homes have recurring problems. Your state survey agency can also send recent inspection reports.
  8. Visit at least twice, once unannounced. Go at a mealtime or on a weekend. Watch how staff speak to residents, how quickly call lights are answered and whether the building smells clean. Ask the administrator how they corrected their last citations.

Green flags and red flags at a glance

Green flagsRed flags
3+ stars for health inspections and staffing1-star inspection rating, or Special Focus Facility / candidate status
RN and total nurse hours above the state average, including weekendsRed abuse icon
Low staff and administrator turnoverHarm-level or repeat citations for the same problem
No fines or payment denials in the last 3 yearsRecent fines, payment denials or a recent ownership change
Chain average of 3+ stars5-star quality measures but 1–2 stars for inspections and staffing
Trophy icon plus a clean inspection reportStaff who can’t answer how citations were corrected

Other places to check nursing home ratings

  • State inspection reports and licensing sites. Many states publish their own inspection findings and complaint results, sometimes more current than Care Compare.
  • Long-term care ombudsman programs. Find yours through the National Long-Term Care Ombudsman Resource Center.
  • Consumer advocates. The Long Term Care Community Coalition (nursinghome411.org) publishes staffing and enforcement data for every certified home.
  • Online reviews. These can show patterns in families’ experiences, but anyone can post them, so use them alongside, not instead of, inspection data.

If you’re still deciding whether a nursing home is the right level of care, see when to move from assisted living to a nursing home and what Medicare pays for in a nursing home.

Ready to compare options? Browse senior living and care providers by state and city, or search the memory care directory if your loved one has dementia.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good nursing home rating?

Four or five stars overall is above average, but look at the parts too. A good target is at least 3 stars for health inspections and staffing, no abuse icon, and no Special Focus Facility status. A 4-star home with a strong inspection record is often a better choice than a 5-star home whose rating comes mainly from self-reported quality measures.

How often are Medicare nursing home ratings updated?

Care Compare updates inspection results monthly, and staffing and quality measures quarterly. A home’s rating can change from month to month as new inspections are added.

Why did a nursing home’s star rating drop?

Common reasons are a new inspection with serious citations, a new abuse icon, lower staffing or higher turnover, or a methodology change. The July 2026 refresh raised quality-measure thresholds, and the July 2025 change to two inspection cycles also moved many ratings. Ask the home to explain any recent drop.

Are 1-star nursing homes always bad?

Not always, but treat a 1-star rating as a serious warning. Because inspection stars are graded on a curve, the bottom 20% in every state get 1 star. Read the inspection report: if the citations are about paperwork and the home has since fixed them, it may be acceptable. If they involve resident harm, abuse or repeat problems, look elsewhere.

What does the trophy icon on Care Compare mean?

The gold trophy, added on 8 October 2026, marks homes eligible for CMS’s shorter risk-based inspection. They have a 5-star overall rating, accurate data, no recent harm-level citations and no recent ownership change. It’s a positive sign but not a guarantee, so still read the inspection report.

Does Medicare rate assisted living facilities?

No. CMS only rates Medicare- and Medicaid-certified nursing homes. Assisted living is licensed by each state, so check your state licensing agency for inspection reports. See assisted living requirements for how states regulate it.

Can I trust online reviews of nursing homes?

Use them as one signal. Reviews can show patterns, such as slow call-light response or poor food, but they are unverified and can be posted by staff or competitors. Inspection reports and staffing data from CMS are more reliable.

Sources

Need help choosing care?

Answer a few quick questions and we’ll recommend options and next steps for your situation. Free, with no obligation.

How it works